• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SMSF Loan Experts

It's not complicated when it's done right
Speak to one of our SMSF Loan specialists today 1300 781 680
  • Call 1300 781 680
  • Home
  • Is This You?
    • I Don’t Have An SMSF, but I’d Like One
    • I Have A SMSF Already
  • How We Help
    • Residential SMSF Loans
    • Commercial SMSF Loans
    • SMSF Setup
    • SMSF Refinance
    • SMSF Lending Strategy
    • Bad Credit SMSF Loans
    • NDIS Property Investment
  • Client Reviews
  • FAQs
  • News
  • About
  • Enquire Now
You are here: Home / SMSF Loans / Overcoming The Perils of Bank Valuations

8 years ago, we saw the need in a growing market for lending experts who specialise in SMSF. Our team now combines years of experience through every aspect of self-managed super funds. Together, we organise more limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBA or SMSF loans) in a week than most other brokers or bank branches in a year. Here we share some of our insights as well as SMSF news with you.

Our expertise has been sought by and seen in Australian Broker, the Herald Sun, Money and Mamamia.

Make sure you get the right SMSF lending advice. Send us a message or call SMSF Loan Experts on 1300 781 680.

Property Valuation

Overcoming The Perils of Bank Valuations

December 16, 2016 By SMSF Loan Experts

Property valuation is supposed to be a science, using facts, mostly comparable sales in this case, to ascertain the value of a property which is offered as a security for a loan to a lender. How much a specific security is worth is going to define how much the said lender is willing to lend against it.

Each lender in Australia has a valuers panel, which is made of all the valuation firms around the country which meet this lender’s requirements. When a loan application is received, or in some cases even before the it is lodged, most lender will request a valuation from a randomly chosen valuer on their panel and use that report as their reference regarding the value of that security.

Aside from putting a value on a property, a valuation report will also rank it for risk for 8 categories with a score of 1 meaning very low risk and a score of 5 meaning high risk. It will also give an appraisal of what rent the property would return if it was used as an investment property.

What could possibly go wrong?

It was over 8 years ago but I still remember the 1st time I saw it: two apartments, with the exact same floor plan and finish, on the same floor valued on the same day for the same bank by two different valuers on that bank’s panel. One of the valuation came back on purchase price at $405,000 while the second one was returned at $350,000… Since then, I have seen this again and again, right up to yesterday when an apartment which was purchased for $495,000 was valued on contract price by a valuer, after an initial valuation last week was received for $420,000.

I have a property valued at $750,000 for a refinance sold within 3 months of that valuation for $870,000 and the list goes on.

Issues With Bank Valuations

If only bank valuations were not so crucial…

A low valuation can have incredibly harmful consequences on a buyer, from increasing the cost of buying (i.e. triggering mortgage insurance, requiring a second mortgage) to losing a deposit for buyers who can not settle altogether.

To make matters worse, lender will always work on the lowest valuation they have on file, so what has been seen can not be unseen! Once a valuation is in and if it is not suitable, a borrower is forced to go to another lender and hope another firm is chosen to value the property. For some it is okay but for some others, their circumstances may limit the amount of lenders they can use, sometime down to only one.

Risk – Even when a valuation comes back on contract price, the valuer may have decided to rank it 5 for risk on one of the 8 categories mentioned above and that would be enough to make the security unusable for some lenders or reduced the amount others are willing to lend against it.

Rent – This one is crucial for clients with tight servicing. We recently had one half a duplex valued for an SMSF loan and received an amazingly non sensical valuations a) Even though the other half of the duplex was sold for $435,000 a few months earlier, the valuer decided that this half was only worth $415,000 by using other comparable sales (i.e. how could they possibly be more relevant?) and b) even though the property had been tenanted to the current tenants for >12 months (and they had just resigned a 12 months lease) for $430 per week, the valuer thought that the rental value of the property was $400 per week!

In this instance, the SMSF was cashed up so the low value was no concern but the income situation was very tight and the reduced rent meant that the loan amount had to be reduced, forcing the trustees to contribute some of their savings into the SMSF: simply insane!

Comments – As if there was not enough scope for valuers to ruin people’s lives with their clearly subjective opinions, they are also providing the lenders with some thoughts which may fall outside of the other criteria mentioned before. There’s an endless list of things that can comment on which may jeopardize a finance application. For example, I’ve seen valuer alerting the lender that a specific property was a serviced apartment when it was not. Unfortunately, serviced apartments were not acceptable securities for this lender…

So what can be done about poor valuations?

Theoretically, a valuation can be argued if mistaken but in practice it consistently turns out to be a draining, long process with little chances of success. To be fair, we have successfully challenged valuers on a number of occasions but that’s a very difficult path to embark on.

Raise additional funds through other means: if a low valuation reduces the amount that can be borrowed, depending on the borrower(s)’ circumstances there could be other means to raise the funds needed for settlement. It could be through a personal loan, a peer to peer loan, a guarantee from parents or equity in another property.

Chose your valuer: it’s just that simple! A few select lenders, including for SMSF loans, will let you chose a lender from their panel to complete the valuation. Oh joy! All that is left to do is order upfront valuations until a suitable valuer can be found and then request that firm to be used by one such lender.

That’s assuming that a suitable valuer can be found which is not a given, since the very method they use to value property is extremely limited. Unfortunately, on some occasions the best that can be done is damage control.

If you experience issues with a bank valuation, please contact us or call us on 1300 781 680.

* The information contained in this blog is general information only. No part of this blog is to be construed as a solicitation to buy or sell any security or financial product. The author, in preparing this blog, did not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs of any particular person. Before acting on any information or advice in this document, you should consider the appropriateness of it (and any relevant product) having regard to your circumstances. You should also seek independent financial advice prior to acquiring a financial product.

  • 1Share on Facebook
  • 0Share on Twitter
  • 1Share on LinkedIn

Filed Under: SMSF Loans, SMSF Property Investment

Primary Sidebar

Get in Touch

Have a question about SMSF Lending that you'd like answered? We'd love to hear from you. Send us a message or call us directly on 1300 781 680.







    Please send me important SMSF updates.

    Recent Posts

    Common Mistakes To Avoid When Making Improvements To Your SMSF Property

    If you’re wondering if you can renovate your SMSF investment property, the short answer is ‘maybe’. The long answer depends on a few different factors, including what type of renovation you’re looking to do and the source of your funds. Choose your scenario below for more details on renovating your property. Your self-managed super fund […]

    SMSF Rental Property Rules: Can I Stay There While It’s Vacant?

    While purchasing an investment property through your self-managed super fund comes with incredible taxation advantages, it does not come with the same benefits of owning a holiday home under your own name. Owning an investment property at the beach or another seasonal tourist location can be an easy and cost-effective way to secure accommodation for […]

    Avoid These Common Mistakes when Running an SMSF

    When it comes to running a self-managed super fund, the good news is that most people are doing the right thing, but there are so many rules and regulations concerning SMSFs, which can make some aspects a little tricky to keep on top of. While SMSF regulations exist to keep things in line, we’re all […]

    Benefits of an Offset Account for you SMSF Loan

    If your Self Managed Super Fund is holding cash reserves and generating a dismal return, we might have the answer for you — you could reap the benefits of an offset account. Whether you’re keeping cash for liquidity reasons or simply waiting to find the perfect asset to invest in, this feature is a great […]

    Refinance SMSF Loan: Your Questions Answered + How to Get Approved

    Refinancing your SMSF loan could save you thousands of dollars and could potentially add up to hundreds of thousands by the time you are ready to retire. We address the top concerns regarding SMSF loan refinance. Eligibility Criteria to Refinance SMSF Loan For SMSF loan providers to consider offering finance to SMSFs, the fund must […]

    Impact of coronavirus on SMSFs

    As we are all well aware, the Coronavirus pandemic has significantly impacted the way the world works regarding our lifestyle, work-life and education. The extraordinary effect it’s had on the economy has meant that many industries have needed to tighten regulation and introduce unsustainable policies in the interim to endure the uncertain conditions we’re inevitably […]

    What is salary sacrifice and what does it mean for SMSF loans

    In Australia, employers must contribute 9.5% of an employee’s wage into the employee’s chosen superannuation fund. For example, someone earning a wage of $100,000 a year will see a $9,500 contributions made to his or her superannuation fund over 12 months. Unlike the top dollars of that person’s income which are taxed at 39%, the […]

    Setting Up Your Retirement Through an SMSF Loan

    There’s a growing number of people taking advantage of their Self-Managed Superannuation Funds. Recently, the Australian Taxation Office released statistics on SMSFs derived from annual data for 2016, which also included the type of investments the trustees chose as well as the amount of SMSF money invested in different types of asset. In the data […]

    Why proposed SMSF lending changes are misplaced

    Property affordability is high on the political agenda nowadays and by the sound of things, Mr Shorten is not going to let facts get in the way of a bit of useless class warfare for as long as he’s seen by his base as hurting the “wealthy”. Unless of course he’s trying to please some […]

    What You Need To Be Aware Of When Using An SMSF To Buy Property

    This is the full transcript of our popular video “The Pros & Cons of Using Super for Property Investment“. I just wanted to talk to you about something that’s really interesting. We talk to a lot of people and generally what we find is that people either hate self managed super funds or they really […]

    Your Questions

    Do you have a topic or question around SMSF Lending you'd like us to write about? You can simply send us a message letting us know what you'd like to hear from us on, and we'll do our best to address your question or topic in our upcoming posts.

    Footer

    Quick Find Index

    SMSF Property Loans
    SMSF Commercial Loans
    Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements – LRBA
    SMSF Setup
    Blog
    Sitemap

    Melbourne Office

    Suite 2, 54 Davis Avenue
    South Yarra VICTORIA 314

    1300 781 680
    SMSF Loan Experts is an authorised credit representative (CR No. 471777) of Australian Finance Group Ltd (Australian Credit Licence No.389087). Copyright © 2021 SMSF Loan Experts | Privacy | Site by Matt Angel
    • Call 1300 781 680
    • Home
    • Is This You?
      • I Don’t Have An SMSF, but I’d Like One
      • I Have A SMSF Already
      • Back
    • How We Help
      • Residential SMSF Loans
      • Commercial SMSF Loans
      • SMSF Setup
      • SMSF Refinance
      • SMSF Lending Strategy
      • Bad Credit SMSF Loans
      • NDIS Property Investment
      • Back
    • Client Reviews
    • FAQs
    • News
    • About
    • Enquire Now