Speak to one of our SMSF Loan specialists today 1300 781 680 Enquire now
  • Call 1300 781 680
  • Home
  • Is This You?
    • I Don’t Have An SMSF, but I’d Like One
    • I Have A SMSF Already
  • How We Help
    • Residential SMSF Loans
    • Commercial SMSF Loans
    • SMSF Setup
    • SMSF Refinance
    • SMSF Lending Strategy
    • Bad Credit SMSF Loans
    • Low Doc SMSF Loans
  • Client Reviews
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements / Why proposed SMSF lending changes are misplaced

8 years ago, we saw the need in a growing market for lending experts who specialise in SMSF. Our team now combines years of experience through every aspect of self-managed super funds. Together, we organise more limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBA or SMSF loans) in a week than most other brokers or bank branches in a year. Here we share some of our insights as well as SMSF news with you.

Our expertise has been sought by and seen in Australian Broker, the Herald Sun, Money and Mamamia.

Make sure you get the right SMSF lending advice. Send us a message or call SMSF Loan Experts on 1300 781 680.

Why proposed SMSF lending changes are misplaced

April 26, 2017 By SMSF Loan Experts

Property affordability is high on the political agenda nowadays and by the sound of things, Mr Shorten is not going to let facts get in the way of a bit of useless class warfare for as long as he’s seen by his base as hurting the “wealthy”. Unless of course he’s trying to please some influential lobbies such as industry superannuation funds who have been bleeding business to SMSFs without finding any commercial answer for such a long time? Either way, he allowed himself some very uneducated comments.

Restricting SMSF lending

Mr Shorten stated among other non sense that the real estate market was overheated, partly because of “wealthy Self Managed super funds” and therefore a ban on SMSF loans would help cool it down (afr.com/news/politics/labor-escalates-housing-war-with-smsf-ban-proposal-20170420-gvoqme).

He did not feel the need, perhaps because he does not understand it, to detail that the overheating only affects a select number of postcodes in Sydney and Melbourne and that the rest of the country can certainly do with willing buyers (ask anyone in Perth if they need the market to cool down…).

Negative gearing & SMSF lending

It’s also worth noting an interesting discrepancy between how he addresses negative gearing and SMSF lending. According to Mr Shorten both are causing an overheated real estate market but one (negative gearing) he will restrict to new dwelling to stimulate new supply to the market, while the other (SMSF loans) he will abolish altogether. It’s a strange to say the least – would not the same remedy work for both if the concern was indeed what he claims it is?

A few facts and thoughts about SMSF gearing that Mr Shorten may have overlooked

According to the ATO (ato.gov.au/about-ato/research-and-statistics/in-detail/super-statistics/smsf/self-managed-super-fund-statistical-report-june-2016/?page=3), as of June 2016, SMSFs own $68.5 million worth of commercial properties and 24.3 millions of residential properties securing 21.8 million worth of loans.

That’s an overall 23.52% loan to value ratio, which hardly sounds like a debt driven investment trend.
Based on my experience organizing LRBAs for SMSF, the “wealthy” argument from Mr Shorten might be politically rewarding but is the most incorrect one all the same, as the wealthier the SMSF, the lower the lending.

Small balance SMSF trustees consistently are the one seeking higher loan to value ratio SMSF loans, while medium size balance SMSF tend to gear less and really wealthy SMSF very little or not at all.
A ban on SMSF loan will mostly hurt smaller funds and let the wealthy ones continue without much disturbance. It’s sadly ironic that a measure presented to curb the rich’s bad behavior is going to mostly hurt the suburban mums and dads who are trying hard not to end up on the pension.

The questionable market impact of SMSF lending restricions

The above figures may seem like big numbers but they need to be put in perspective. According to the ABS (abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/6416.0), the total value of residential properties in Australia was 6,438,537.30 millions as of December 2016. That means that SMSF currently own 0.038% of properties in Australia.

Considering the proposed ban on lending would only affect, out of that tiny percentage, only those needing SMSF loans, it’s questionable at best how much cooling it will provide to the market. You would also have noted that by and large, most of the SMSF direct property ownership is through commercial properties, a market which does not really need any cooling to start with.

Many small business owners purchase their premises through their SMSF to free cash in their business which can subsequently be used to invest in the said business. At a time when it is extremely difficult for these businesses to raise funds, this ban on borrowing could cool down small non mining business investment. That would be a real shame since we constantly hear the reserve bank impatiently whining about how there is not enough of it.

Eventually, Australia may learn the hard way that trying to manipulate the market through regulatory changes may have unpredictable, uncontrollable and undesirable consequences. One should be careful about what one is wishing for. A solid real estate market is at the heart of the economic stability of this country and should not be taken for granted.

Filed Under: Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements, SMSF Property Investment

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Get in Touch

Have a question about SMSF Lending that you'd like answered? We'd love to hear from you. Send us a message or call us directly on 1300 781 680.

Recent Posts

What is salary sacrifice and what does it mean for SMSF loans

In Australia, employers must contribute 9.5% of an employee’s wage into the employee’s chosen superannuation fund. For example, someone earning a wage of $100,000 a year will see a $9,500 contributions made to his or her superannuation fund over 12 months. Unlike the top dollars of that person’s income which are taxed at 39%, the […]

Setting Up Your Retirement Through an SMSF Loan

There’s a growing number of people taking advantage of their Self-Managed Superannuation Funds. Recently, the Australian Taxation Office released statistics on SMSFs derived from annual data for 2016, which also included the type of investments the trustees chose as well as the amount of SMSF money invested in different types of asset. In the data […]

Choosing the right property for your SMSF investment

This is the full transcript of our popular video “What type of properties can an SMSF purchase?“. Let’s talk about what kind of properties can a self managed super fund purchase – a question we get asked a lot. We find that a lot of our clients are feeling a little bit exotic when it […]

Understanding the borrowing or purchasing capacity of your SMSF

This is the full transcript of our popular video “Boosting your SMSFs purchasing capacity“. Okay so one of the conversations we’re having really regularly with our clients is that they get very frustrated with the borrowing capacity or purchasing power of their self managed super fund. SMSF loans are difficult to service and we are […]

What makes property investment through Super so popular?

This is the full transcript of our popular video “Why SMSFs are such a popular vehicle for property investment“. I just wanted to have a quick chat about why people invest in property through their self managed super fund – why is it so popular? Why are we so busy at the moment writing loans […]

Why proposed SMSF lending changes are misplaced

Property affordability is high on the political agenda nowadays and by the sound of things, Mr Shorten is not going to let facts get in the way of a bit of useless class warfare for as long as he’s seen by his base as hurting the “wealthy”. Unless of course he’s trying to please some […]

Structuring Your SMSF to Include a Property

This is the full transcript of our popular video “Adding a Property To Your SMSF with an SMSF Loan“. Okay so in our previous video we showed you the structure that would allow a self managed super fund to purchase a property using a loan. What I want to show you now is, briefly, how […]

What You Need To Be Aware Of When Using An SMSF To Buy Property

This is the full transcript of our popular video “The Pros & Cons of Using Super for Property Investment“. I just wanted to talk to you about something that’s really interesting. We talk to a lot of people and generally what we find is that people either hate self managed super funds or they really […]

How To Setup Your SMSF To Borrow For Investment

This is the full transcript of our popular video “Structuring Your SMSF to Borrow and Invest in Property“. Let’s talk about Self Managed Super Funds buying property for investment. So today we’re going to tackle the structure that’s used for a self managed super fund to invest in property, and there’s a few entities that […]

Why are SMSF loans more expensive than standard residential loans?

We get asked this question a lot – and while at first it may seem to be because the banks, the reality in this instance is that the blame is mostly on the regulator. What is going to define the cost of a loan to a lender is the amount of capital they will have […]

Your Questions

Do you have a topic or question around SMSF Lending you'd like us to write about? You can simply send us a message letting us know what you'd like to hear from us on, and we'll do our best to address your question or topic in our upcoming posts.
Quick Find Index
  • SMSF Property Loans
  • SMSF Commercial Loans
  • Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements - LRBA
  • SMSF Setup
Sydney Office
  • Level 4, 220 George St,
  • Sydney NSW 2000
1300 781 680
Melbourne Office
  • Suite 2, 54 Davis Avenue
  • South Yarra VICTORIA 314
1300 781 680

SMSF Loan Experts is an authorised credit representative (CR No. 471777) of Australian Finance Group Ltd (Australian Credit Licence No.389087).

Copyright © 2019 SMSF Loan Experts | Privacy | Site by Matt Angel

  • Call 1300 781 680
  • Home
  • Is This You?
    • I Don’t Have An SMSF, but I’d Like One
    • I Have A SMSF Already
    • Back
  • How We Help
    • Residential SMSF Loans
    • Commercial SMSF Loans
    • SMSF Setup
    • SMSF Refinance
    • SMSF Lending Strategy
    • Bad Credit SMSF Loans
    • Low Doc SMSF Loans
    • Back
  • Client Reviews
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact